Chrysippus argues that as a building requires a building , the world requires a builder superior to humankind, but Carneades eviscerate that argument, noting that the former used the question-begging term builder rather than what forms matters. Indeed, the argument itself begs the question of intent that Thales and Strato try to dispel from empirical matters.
Carneades thus eviscerates teleological eons before David Hume does. Carneades is then the first atheologian as well as the first ignostic.
Azn4. andRikki.. and others, please add content to this blog! It is for us all to better our argumentation pro or con!
How could a disembodied being be able to act and to think without a mind in a brain per the argument from physical mind/ We know only of minds in brains, and therefore, theologians and others merely assert without the merest piece of evidence that God can exist without a brain.
" God is in a worse position than the Scarecrow who had a body to which a mnd could enter whilst He has neither. He is that married bachelor and thus cannot exist. No wonder He is ineffable!" Ignostic Morgan
http://ignosticmorgan.glogspot.com
http://ignosticmorgan.wordpresss.com
Aucun commentaire:
Enregistrer un commentaire